Democrats are desperate for help.
Former Presidents Clinton, Obama, Biden, and George W. Bush have maintained an unusual silence as President Trump enters his second term. This has raised concerns, especially among Democratic critics, who believe their voices are sorely needed in these times. With Trump’s aggressive actions, including challenging court rulings and taking steps to consolidate power, many argue that these former leaders, who have firsthand knowledge of the importance of respecting the separation of powers, should be more vocal.
Democratic strategist Joel Payne expressed frustration, stating that “former presidents know better than anyone the value of presidential restraint and the importance of respecting constitutional boundaries.” He suggested that Trump’s moves to bypass court orders and expand executive power should be alarming to all who care about the integrity of the American system.
An Obama aide also echoed these concerns, pointing out that the time to speak up isn’t after Trump defies legal rulings—it’s now, when the country is at a crossroads. Despite these calls, former presidents have largely stayed silent. During his first month in office, President Trump has implemented significant changes, such as cutting back on the federal workforce, giving Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) access to sensitive payment systems, and pushing for changes to birthright citizenship.
Though Clinton, Biden, and Obama previously warned of the dangers posed by a second Trump term, their criticisms have largely been contained to general remarks about the threat to democracy. Biden, in particular, raised alarms in his farewell address, warning of an emerging oligarchy that threatens democratic institutions. Obama, too, has voiced concerns about the erosion of democratic norms and the rise of authoritarianism, but has refrained from directly addressing Trump’s presidency.
Interestingly, former President George W. Bush, despite being a Republican, has also refrained from public criticism. Bush has always respected the office, preferring not to step into a debate with the sitting president, a stance many attribute to his personal philosophy of supporting the current leader.
In the past, ex-presidents typically avoid publicly criticizing their successors, maintaining the tradition of supporting the office regardless of political differences. However, Trump’s unique approach to governance has made this tradition more difficult to uphold. As Republican strategist Susan Del Percio put it, speaking out against Trump is a “fruitless effort” for former presidents. “They know they can’t influence him,” she said. “He’s a man who believes he knows best and won’t be swayed by anyone.”
Ultimately, many Republicans argue that the focus should remain on upholding constitutional principles rather than relying on former presidents to weigh in. Trump’s approach to the presidency is shaping a new chapter in American politics, one that challenges traditional norms—and that’s something only time will tell how it will affect future presidencies.