Here’s what some Republicans are saying.
In a recent opinion article, Republican strategist Susan Del Percio sought to temper concerns about Donald Trump’s proposed tariff plan, suggesting that while Trump’s bold statements often grab headlines, they may not always result in action. Del Percio, who has been a vocal critic of Trump’s influence over the GOP, argued that just because the president-elect promises drastic measures doesn’t mean he will follow through.
Trump’s plan to impose a 25% tariff on goods from Mexico and Canada is tied to his demand that both countries take stronger actions to curb illegal immigration and the flow of fentanyl into the United States. In addition, he proposed an extra 10% tariff on Chinese imports until Beijing takes steps to halt fentanyl production. While these tariffs could generate significant revenue—estimated at $266 billion if trade remains stable—there are concerns that they would burden American families, importers, and businesses with higher prices.
Del Percio pointed to a 2019 instance when Trump threatened a 5% tariff on Mexico over immigration but quickly backed down after securing a deal with the country. This episode, she suggested, illustrates that Trump often uses tough rhetoric but doesn’t always follow through with his most extreme proposals. The strategist also noted that Trump’s recent talks with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau haven’t led to any concrete policy changes yet.
Despite these negotiations, Del Percio expressed concerns over the long-term impact of Trump’s approach. Republican lawmakers, like Senator Rand Paul, have voiced skepticism about using tariffs to fund tax cuts, arguing that they function like a sales tax, which disproportionately affects consumers. Paul also criticized the use of military force for domestic immigration enforcement, a move Trump has floated in his rhetoric.
While Del Percio acknowledged that Trump’s policies have generated concern, especially among businesses and undocumented workers, she urged Republicans to be cautious in their reactions. The key takeaway, she suggested, is that Trump’s plans remain largely unexecuted—so while Republicans should stay vigilant, they shouldn’t panic prematurely.
For conservative voters, this analysis serves as a reminder that while Trump’s bold policies may seem alarming, history shows that his tactics often involve negotiation and recalibration. As the new administration prepares to take office, Republicans must keep a clear-eyed perspective, avoiding both excessive fear and misplaced optimism.